Skip to main content

My Right Wing Agenda

Go Search
Home
  

My Right Wing Agenda > Posts > Why we should change the national anthem(s)
Why we should change the national anthem(s)

Firstly both the Welsh and the Scots have their own national anthem, but the English anthem is the same as the British one. Lets take the British anthem firsts. I don't feel that our current national anthem "God save the Queen" can be used as a anthem for all of Great Britain basically because of the verse which whilst dropped later stated "Rebellious Scots to crush" makes this an uncomfortable song to have as the national anthem. IMHO pomp and circumstance march number one is a much more suitable contender, the lyrics are more suitable to Britain and make reference to our glory days at the height of the empire. Apart from this I don't know who ever though God Save the Queen was a good tune it sounds awful has no umph to it. At the last night of the Proms we all look forward to Land of Hope and Glory it has that real feel good proud feeling and it to touches on our Christian heritage which I feel we are sadly loosing.

England deserves its own anthem and God Save the Queen just doesn't cut it for all the reasons above with the possible exception of the line about us Scots. Another argument for not having god save the queen is that probably about ΒΌ of the country are basically republican, I certainly used to be very republican but mellowed in the years (mainly as I can't come up with a better solution at present.. though I suspect a flawed solution might be better than the status quo once our majesty passes on and hands the head of state on to Charles.. a debate for another day). Since we have nabbed Pomp and Circumstance march number one for Britain that really does only leave one other track, which sounds as good on the football terraces as it does at the proms and that is Jerusalem, by William Blake and set to music by Elgar. It not only has that proud sounding tune that is necessary for a anthem but again makes good references to our heritage as a Christian country.

Let me know your thoughts Gordon.

Comments

A Comment and a Correction

I agree that GSTQ is a terribly uninspiring piece of music. I think we probably could find something that we in Engalnd could claim as "our" anthem. However, I do not believe that one has to be right wing to believe this. An argumane for another day, perhaps...

The *composer* of the musical setting for Blake's words, "Jerusalem" was not Elgar. It was Hubert Parry who composed the piece specifically for a meeting promoting women's sufferage in 1916. In 1922, Elgar scored the orchestral version that is now so familiar to us all. It seems that, having heard this version, George V suggested it should replace "God Save the King" as the national anthem!

TallPaul
at 24/04/2008 14:19

Change it, for goodness sake!

Definitely change it.  I would rather change the British National Anthem from 'God Save the Queen' to something like 'Jerusalem' or 'I Vow to thee my Country', a song with more flare, than recreate and entirely new 'English' National Anthem.  Look at les Marseillaises, the french national anthem.  I'm not even French, but I feel pride...BUT I'M NOT EVEN FRENCH!

It is an amazing song, which can't be out done.

We should change it to a song which already has some history, than compose an entirely new one.

Main candidates in my opinion:

1. I Vow to thee My Country
2. Jerusalem
3. Land of Hope and Glory
4. God is our Strength and Refuge (Dambusters)

God forbid the government should commission a new ''Politically Correct'' hymn.

And lastly, how on earth do we actually GET the thing CHANGED?
at 31/08/2008 03:51

Ye can keep yer anthem

Being Scottish I dont realy much care for what is known as the britsh national anthem mainly because we have our own and pretty soon Scotland will be an independant nation again. So I couldn't care less if you sang about crushing scots or what.
 I suppose you are right though, it is a very dull tune, so may therefore suggest it is changed to one of the following:

a) The tune from the archers
b) agadoo
c) vindaloo by fat les (just about sums up your culture)

Ahra best

Big Jock
 
at 05/04/2009 22:52

Chris

I recently watched last night of the proms and as always was stirred by the singing of Land of hope and glory, as I was when it was used for England medal ceremonies at the Manchester Commonwealth games. God save the queen should be replaced by this wonderfully inspiring tune as our national anthem and if we must then GSTQ can be kept as a personal anthem for the monarch when they are in attendance at a fuction. Similar to that used by the US president.
at 18/09/2009 20:48

Add Comment

Items on this list require content approval. Your submission will not appear in public views until approved by someone with proper rights. More information on content approval.

Title


Body *


Today's Date *

Todays Date
Attachments